Shopify vs. Etsy: Which Is Better for Sellers?

Shopify is best for building a fully customizable online store with complete control over branding and growth. Etsy, on the other hand, connects you to a large, ready-made audience of buyers, especially for handmade, vintage, or craft items.

Key Differences:

• Shopify:
  • Create your own store with a custom domain.
  • Sell any legal product.
  • Full brand control and advanced marketing tools.
  • Monthly plans start at $5; per-sale fees are lower for high-volume sellers.
• Etsy:
  • Use a marketplace with 95–96 million active buyers.
  • Focuses on handmade, vintage, and craft products.
  • Easy setup but limited customization.
  • Pay-per-transaction model (6.5% fee + 20¢ listing fee).

Quick Comparison:

Bottom Line: Start with Etsy for quick exposure, then move to Shopify for more control and scalability as your business grows.

What Each Platform Does

Shopify Basics

Shopify is an all-in-one e-commerce platform that lets sellers create and manage their own online stores. It gives you complete control over your brand and how you present it. Here’s what Shopify offers:

• A custom domain name (e.g., yourbrand.com) to establish your identity
• Over 70 customizable, no-code themes to design your store
• The ability to list unlimited products in any legal category
• Full access to customer data, helping you build direct relationships
• Built-in security features and payment processing

Shopify’s checkout system is designed to boost conversion rates by an average of 15%, making it a great option for businesses focused on scaling and building a recognizable brand.

Next, let’s look at Etsy’s marketplace-driven approach for sellers.

Etsy Basics

Etsy is a marketplace tailored for handmade goods, vintage items, and craft supplies. It’s perfect for sellers who want quick access to an audience without building a store from scratch.

Here’s what Etsy brings to the table:

• A standardized shop URL (etsy.com/shop/YourShopName) for easy setup
• Built-in trust features and traffic generated by Etsy’s search algorithm
• A specialized focus on handmade, vintage, and craft items

The key difference between the two platforms lies in their business models. Shopify is ideal for merchants who want full control to grow their brands independently. Etsy, on the other hand, offers a ready-made marketplace with built-in traffic but limits customization options.

Many sellers start on Etsy to take advantage of its organic traffic and then transition to Shopify when they’re ready to scale and take control of their brand.

Your choice should match your business goals. Shopify is better for creating a scalable, distinct brand, while Etsy works well for those focusing on handmade or vintage items and leveraging an established marketplace of eager buyers.

Etsy vs. Shopify: Which One Is Better for Your Business?

Fees and Pricing

Once you’ve reviewed each platform’s features, it’s crucial to understand their fee structures to ensure they fit your business needs.

Shopify Costs

Shopify provides five monthly plans designed for businesses of different sizes:

• Starter: $5/month (basic selling tools)
• Basic: $39/month (complete store functionality)
• Shopify: $105/month (additional tools and reduced fees)
• Advanced: $399/month (advanced reports and lower payment processing fees)
• Plus: Starting at $2,000/month (enterprise-level features)

Payment processing fees with Shopify Payments:

In contrast, Etsy operates on a fee-per-transaction model.

Etsy Costs

• Listing Fee: 20¢ per item (renewed every 4 months)
• Transaction Fee: 6.5% of the total sale price
• Payment Processing: 3% + 25¢ per transaction

Etsy also offers optional subscriptions like Etsy Plus ($10/month) and Pattern ($15/month).

Cost Breakdown

Here’s an example of fees for selling a $50 item:

Additional Notes

• Shopify store domains typically cost around $12 annually.
• Etsy charges a 12% fee on sales from off-site ads if sellers exceed $10,000 in annual sales.

Shopify’s fixed pricing works well for high-volume sellers, while Etsy’s transaction-based fees are ideal for those testing the waters or selling at a lower volume.

Next, we’ll explore how each platform handles store design, which plays a key role in choosing the right platform.

Store Design Options

Shopify and Etsy take very different approaches to design and customization.

Shopify Design Tools

Shopify provides over 70 themes that you can customize to fit your brand. These themes let sellers tweak colors, fonts, and layouts. You can also create custom product pages, personalize your checkout process, and design branded navigation menus. Plus, Shopify integrates with more than 8,000 apps to expand functionality. Another big plus? You can use a custom domain (e.g., YourBrand.com) to strengthen your brand identity. Now, let’s see how Etsy stacks up.

Etsy Design Rules

Etsy’s design is more rigid. It uses a standardized template that ensures consistency across all shops but limits customization options. Sellers can only adjust their shop banners and profile pictures within this fixed layout.

sbb-itb-6768865

Customer Reach and Marketing

Reaching and engaging customers is just as important as having a great product. Here’s how Etsy and Shopify approach this differently.

Etsy’s Market Access

Etsy gives sellers access to a huge audience – 500 million monthly visitors looking for handmade, vintage, and craft items. This means sellers can start receiving orders quickly. Etsy’s search algorithm helps connect buyers with the right products, so optimizing your listings is key to being noticed.

With 95–96 million active buyers, Etsy is ideal for sellers offering:

• Handmade goods
• Vintage items
• Craft supplies
• Unique, one-of-a-kind products

On the other hand, Shopify focuses on empowering sellers to build their own brand and grow through advanced marketing tools.

Shopify’s Marketing Tools

Shopify doesn’t come with a built-in audience like Etsy. Instead, it provides powerful tools to help sellers market their products and grow their businesses.

Shopify’s features make it easy to collect customer data for retargeting and improve conversion rates. For example, its checkout process alone can boost conversions by 15%. Plus, a one-second improvement in site speed can increase mobile conversions by up to 27%. Shop Pay, Shopify’s payment service with over 150 million users, adds another layer of trust, helping to drive more sales.

"Shopify empowers you to build your own online store whereas Etsy is a marketplace. The Shopify platform enables merchants to build their brands and own their marketing." – Shopify Canada

For sellers who want to establish a strong brand identity, Shopify’s marketing tools allow for:

• Custom email campaigns
• Targeted social media ads
• SEO improvements
• Customer loyalty programs
• In-depth performance tracking

Growth Potential

Each platform brings its own strengths for businesses looking to expand. Let’s take a closer look at how Shopify and Etsy handle growth.

Shopify Growth Tools

Shopify is designed to support businesses aiming to grow, no matter their size. Here’s a breakdown of what it offers:

Key features that make Shopify scalable include:

• Support for unlimited products and multi-location inventory
• Multi-currency and multi-language capabilities
• Tools to capture and analyze customer data
• Automated marketing campaigns to streamline outreach

On top of that, Shopify offers lower per-sale fees and greater design flexibility compared to Etsy, making it a strong choice for businesses looking to scale.

Etsy Size Limits

Etsy, on the other hand, has some built-in limitations that can make scaling a challenge:

• With over 100 million listings, standing out and building a unique brand can be tough.
• Fees can add up quickly, cutting into profits as sales grow.
• Access to customer data is restricted, limiting insights into your audience.
• Marketing options are fixed and must follow Etsy’s marketplace rules.

These constraints mean that while Etsy is great for getting started, many sellers outgrow its structure and look for platforms like Shopify to support larger-scale operations.

Platform Selection Guide

This guide highlights which platform suits different seller needs based on the comparisons above. Here’s a quick breakdown to help match your business to the right platform.

Best Uses for Etsy

Etsy is ideal for sellers offering specific types of products. With a built-in audience of 95–96 million active buyers, it’s a great choice for:

Etsy is a good fit when you:

• Need quick exposure without creating a full marketing strategy.
• Sell products that align with Etsy’s handmade, vintage, or craft supply categories.
• Want to test the market before investing in a dedicated website.
• Have limited time to manage marketing or a website.

For more control and scalability, Shopify may be the better choice.

Best Uses for Shopify

Shopify is a strong option for sellers who want independence and room to grow. Unlike Etsy, it provides a customizable platform for building your brand:

Shopify is best for sellers who:

• Want to create a unique brand identity.
• Need full control over customer relationships and store design.
• Plan to scale beyond a small business.
• Offer products outside of Etsy’s categories.
• Use multiple sales channels to reach customers.

Many sellers start on Etsy to take advantage of its organic traffic, then transition to Shopify as their brand grows and requires more control.

Conclusion

Based on the feature and cost comparisons outlined earlier, the best platform for your business depends on your specific goals and needs.

Shopify is ideal if you’re looking for greater control over your store and the ability to scale. It provides the tools needed to establish a strong, independent brand. On the other hand, Etsy is perfect for accessing a large marketplace quickly, especially for sellers of handmade, vintage, or craft items. With 95–96 million active buyers, Etsy’s pay-as-you-go structure works well for testing demand without a big upfront commitment.

To sum it up, Shopify involves a higher initial cost but offers lower long-term fees and full control over your brand. Etsy, while more affordable at the start, comes with limitations in terms of growth and scalability.

A common strategy is to start on Etsy to gauge market interest and later move to Shopify for more control and expansion opportunities.

FAQs

What should I consider when choosing between Shopify and Etsy to sell handmade products?

When deciding between Shopify and Etsy, consider factors like customization, branding, audience reach, and fees. Shopify is a fully customizable platform where you can create your own branded online store with a custom domain. It’s ideal if you want full control over your site’s design and rely on your own marketing to attract customers.

Etsy, on the other hand, is a marketplace with a built-in audience of shoppers looking for handmade, vintage, and craft items. It’s a great option if you prefer a ready-made customer base but don’t mind limited design customization and using an Etsy subdomain.

For costs, Shopify charges a monthly subscription fee but doesn’t have listing fees, allowing unlimited products. Etsy uses a pay-per-use model, charging $0.20 per listing plus transaction and payment fees. Think about your business goals, budget, and whether you value a custom store or access to an existing marketplace when making your decision.

What are the key differences in fees between Shopify and Etsy for sellers looking to grow their business?

For sellers aiming to grow their business, Shopify typically offers a more cost-effective fee structure compared to Etsy, especially as your product range expands. Shopify does not charge listing fees and allows you to add unlimited products, making it a scalable option for larger inventories. In contrast, Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee per product, which renews every four months if the item doesn’t sell, potentially increasing costs for sellers with extensive catalogs.

Additionally, Shopify does not apply transaction fees when you use Shopify Payments, while Etsy charges a 6.5% transaction fee on each sale. These differences can significantly impact your overall profitability, especially as your business grows.

Can I switch from Etsy to Shopify as my business grows, and what are the advantages of doing so?

Yes, you can switch from Etsy to Shopify as your business expands, and there are several benefits to making this transition. Shopify gives you greater control over your online store by allowing you to fully customize its design and functionality. Unlike Etsy, Shopify enables you to create a unique shopping experience tailored to your brand.

Another key advantage is that Shopify lets you own your customer data, which is essential for building long-term relationships and marketing directly to your audience. Additionally, Shopify often has lower transaction fees and provides tools to help you scale, such as advanced inventory management and integrations with marketing platforms. These features make it an excellent choice for growing businesses looking to establish a strong, independent online presence.

Related posts

• Adobe Commerce vs Shopify: Which One is Right for You?
• Shopify vs. Amazon: Key Differences Explained
• Is Shopify Worth It? Pros & Cons for Sellers
• Shopify vs. Wix: Which One Should You Use?