Shopify vs. Amazon: Key Differences Explained

Choosing between Shopify and Amazon depends on your business goals. Shopify gives you full control over your brand and customer relationships, while Amazon offers access to its massive marketplace and built-in audience. Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Shopify: Best for building a custom online store, owning your customer data, and maintaining full brand control. Ideal for established or niche brands focused on direct-to-consumer (DTC) sales.
• Amazon: Best for reaching a large audience quickly, leveraging Amazon’s fulfillment services (FBA), and selling mass-market products. Perfect for new brands or products with broad appeal.

Quick Comparison

If you want complete control over your brand, Shopify is the better choice. If you’re looking for instant access to a large audience, Amazon is ideal. Many businesses use both platforms to maximize growth.

Platform Features

Shopify Store Creation

Shopify allows merchants to create personalized online stores with complete design flexibility. Using customizable themes and editable code, businesses can tailor their storefronts to reflect their brand. Shopify’s e-commerce toolkit includes:

• Inventory management tools
• Automated order fulfillment
• Marketing campaign features
• Detailed analytics dashboards
• Built-in tools for improving search engine visibility

Now, let’s look at how Amazon’s marketplace features cater to a different set of priorities.

Amazon Marketplace Benefits

Amazon gives sellers access to a massive customer base and easy-to-use selling tools. Key features include:

Feature Comparison

Shopify and Amazon both serve CPG brands but excel in different areas. Here’s a side-by-side look at their features:

Pick the platform that fits your brand’s priority – whether it’s full control over design or instant access to a large marketplace.

Shopify vs Amazon (2024) – Which is Better for Ecommerce?

Customer Base and Reach

Matching your platform’s reach to your CPG growth strategy is a key step in achieving success.

Best Fits for Shopify

Shopify is ideal for brands that prioritize direct customer connections and maintaining control over their branding. It’s particularly suited for:

• Established CPG brands that want to uphold their unique identity and cater to a loyal customer base.
• Niche manufacturers requiring tailored shopping experiences for their specific audience.
• Direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands focused on nurturing customer relationships.

With Shopify’s marketing tools and customization options, brands can design campaigns that resonate directly with their target audience.

Best Fits for Amazon

Amazon, with its 213 million monthly visitors and 40% share of the U.S. ecommerce market, offers unparalleled reach for:

• Mass-market CPG products aiming for wide-scale distribution.
• New brands looking to tap into Amazon’s massive built-in customer base.
• Products with broad appeal that benefit from price and feature comparison shopping.

Amazon’s scale is reflected in its 9.5 million sellers, but this also means fierce competition. However, its trusted reputation and review system can help new products quickly establish credibility.

CPG Brand Considerations

Choosing the right platform depends on how well it aligns with your long-term strategy. Here’s a comparison of key factors for CPG brands:

"Shopify empowers you to build your own online store whereas Amazon is a marketplace. The Shopify platform enables merchants to build their brands and own their marketing. Shopify businesses are scalable allowing you to start out small and grow into a household brand."

Many successful CPG brands use a hybrid approach, leveraging Amazon’s vast reach for exposure while maintaining a Shopify store to foster brand loyalty and offer premium products. This strategy balances Amazon’s scale with Shopify’s branding capabilities, creating a powerful combination for growth.

sbb-itb-6768865

Cost Breakdown

Understanding platform fees is crucial for building a successful eCommerce strategy. Here’s a breakdown of costs for Shopify and Amazon.

Shopify Fees

Shopify offers subscription plans tailored to businesses of different sizes. Here’s a quick overview of their pricing:

*Rates apply when using Shopify Payments.
**Transaction fees are only charged if you use an external payment provider.

Using Shopify Payments eliminates transaction fees, which can significantly reduce costs for businesses with high sales volumes. Additional expenses may include domain registration (around $12/year) and optional premium themes or apps.

Amazon Seller Costs

Amazon uses a different pricing model depending on the plan you choose:

For sellers using Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), extra charges include storage fees, fulfillment fees, and possibly long-term storage fees. However, FBA provides access to Prime customers and Amazon’s logistics network, which can be a game-changer for some businesses.

CPG Cost Analysis

The choice between Shopify and Amazon often depends on sales volume, pricing, and fulfillment needs. Let’s examine a scenario where a typical CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods) brand sells 1,000 units per month:

Shopify’s straightforward cost structure works well for businesses with higher sales volumes. Meanwhile, Amazon’s fees can reduce profit margins, especially for lower-priced products.

To manage costs effectively, focus on:

• Sales Volume and Pricing: Shopify’s flat-rate model is ideal for higher volumes, while Amazon may be better for niche, high-margin products.
• Fulfillment Strategy: FBA simplifies logistics but comes with added expenses.
• Growth Plans: Each platform supports different scaling approaches, so choose based on your long-term goals.

Ultimately, the best platform is the one that aligns with your specific business needs and growth objectives.

Brand Design Control

Design flexibility is a key difference between Shopify and Amazon, especially for CPG brands aiming to create engaging and memorable customer experiences.

Shopify Design Options

Shopify provides tools for:

• Customizing online stores with themes and templates
• Editing code directly (HTML, CSS, Liquid) for advanced design control
• Developing branded content, like blog posts and custom pages

These features are particularly useful for established CPG brands. For instance, Alter Eco, a chocolate manufacturer based in San Francisco, successfully launched three custom Shopify sites with Sleepless Media. These included platforms for their U.S. and Australian direct-to-consumer operations, as well as a dedicated wholesale site.

Amazon Brand Limits

Due to these constraints, about 80% of Amazon sellers also use other platforms to strengthen their brand identity. The limited design options on Amazon make it harder for CPG brands to stand out and develop a unique identity.

CPG Brand Identity

The differences in design control between these platforms directly impact how CPG brands engage with customers. Hassan Alnassir, Founder of Premium Joy, highlights this:

"Maintaining my own standalone website (using Shopify) gives me a better chance to grow the business thanks to the ability to publish blog posts and build an email list, as opposed to merely selling on Amazon… my current focus is building and promoting the business beyond their platform, where it’s easier to stand out in this competitive era".

When choosing between Shopify and Amazon, brands often weigh their priorities:

For CPG brands aiming to build strong customer relationships and maintain consistent branding, Shopify’s design capabilities provide a distinct edge. It allows businesses to craft immersive brand experiences while retaining full control over their online presence.

Shipping and Storage

Effective fulfillment and inventory management are critical for CPG brands to meet customer expectations and maintain profitability.

Shopify Shipping Tools

Shopify provides a range of shipping solutions that give brands control over their fulfillment processes. Key features include:

A recent report highlights that inventory mismanagement costs Shopify sellers nearly $2 trillion annually. While Shopify’s built-in inventory tracking is suitable for smaller operations, larger businesses often turn to specialized apps for more advanced needs.

Amazon FBA Program

Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) offers an all-in-one solution for storage, packing, and shipping. Key benefits include:

However, the COVID-19 pandemic revealed limitations in FBA’s system, such as restrictions on inventory shipments, which created challenges for sellers. These differences underscore the importance of aligning fulfillment strategies with the specific needs of your products.

CPG Shipping Needs

Choosing the right fulfillment strategy is especially important for CPG brands, as they often have unique shipping and storage requirements. Here’s how Shopify and Amazon FBA compare:

For brands dealing with perishable goods, Shopify’s flexibility allows for strategies like FIFO, which helps reduce waste and manage inventory effectively. Its straightforward pricing also minimizes the risk of unexpected expenses caused by overstocking or seasonal demand fluctuations. On the other hand, Amazon FBA can be advantageous for products with extremely tight margins but offers less control over inventory and shipping decisions. Shopify’s approach is better suited for brands requiring specific handling or storage conditions.

Conclusion

Decision Factors

When deciding between Shopify and Amazon, CPG brands should consider several critical factors for long-term success. Amazon currently holds 40% of the U.S. e-commerce market share, showcasing its massive reach.

These factors can help determine which platform aligns best with your business goals.

Platform Choice Guide

Your choice depends on your business stage and priorities:

• Choose Shopify if you:
  • Need complete control over your brand’s identity and customer experience.
  • Want to build direct relationships with your customers.
  • Plan to sell through multiple channels (notably, 80% of Amazon sellers also run their own websites).
  • Have the resources to invest in marketing and driving traffic.
• Choose Amazon if you:
  • Want immediate access to a large, established customer base.
  • Prefer to utilize Amazon’s fulfillment services for logistics.
  • Aim for quick market entry.
  • Sell products with margins that can handle Amazon’s fee structure.

Many CPG brands successfully use both platforms. Shopify often serves as a brand’s central hub, while Amazon provides additional exposure and sales opportunities. By understanding these distinctions, you can make an informed choice to support your business growth.

Related posts

• Amazon vs Shopify: Best Platform for CPG Brands
• Best Ecommerce SEO Platforms to Boost Your Store in 2025
• Adobe Commerce vs Shopify: Which One is Right for You?
• What Does Shopify Do? A Beginner’s Guide