- Pinterest is great for discovery and awareness campaigns with its lower costs (CPMs), longer content lifespan, and keyword targeting. Perfect for CPG brands in beauty, food, and home-related products.
- Facebook excels at conversions and retargeting with its advanced audience targeting, behavioral data, and diverse ad formats. Ideal for driving direct sales and retaining customers.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Primary Intent | Discovery & planning | Engagement & purchasing |
| Cost (CPM) | Lower | Higher |
| Ad Longevity | Long-term visibility | Short-term impact |
| Targeting | Keyword-based, interest-focused | Advanced behavioral targeting |
| Best For | Awareness, inspiration | Conversions, retargeting |
Key Takeaway
Use Pinterest for building awareness early in the customer journey. Then, leverage Facebook to retarget and convert those users into buyers. Both platforms work better together when aligned with your goals. Keep reading for actionable tips to optimize both!
Facebook Ads vs Pinterest Ads: Which Strategy is Better?
Overview of Pinterest and Facebook Ads
Pinterest and Facebook Ads offer two different approaches to digital advertising, each catering to specific marketing goals for CPG brands. Knowing how they differ helps marketers allocate budgets wisely and improve campaign outcomes.
Differences Between Platforms
Pinterest and Facebook vary in terms of user behavior, intent, and how users engage with content. Here’s a quick comparison:
| Platform Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Primary User Intent | Product discovery & planning | Social networking & content consumption |
| Cost Structure | Lower CPM, ideal for awareness | Higher CPM, better for conversions |
| Content Lifespan | Long-lasting content visibility | Short-term engagement focus |
| Ad Format Focus | Visual-heavy formats | Wide variety of formats |
These differences highlight Pinterest’s strength in discovery-based marketing, while Facebook shines in campaigns aimed at driving conversions.
Advantages of Pinterest Ads
Pinterest’s emphasis on visuals makes it a great choice for promoting beauty, food, and home-related products. Its keyword-based targeting and lower CPM rates are perfect for raising brand awareness. Plus, the platform’s extended content lifespan means your ads can engage users over a longer period [1].
Advantages of Facebook Ads
Facebook’s advanced targeting options and versatile ad formats give marketers the tools to build highly effective campaigns. With precise audience segmentation, diverse ad styles, and strong conversion tracking, Facebook is ideal for campaigns focused on customer retention and direct sales [3].
"Facebook often outperforms Pinterest in conversion rates, especially for businesses with longer customer journeys [2]. This makes it particularly valuable for CPG brands focused on driving immediate sales and measuring direct ROI."
For CPG marketers, the choice between Pinterest and Facebook often depends on campaign goals. Pinterest is well-suited for launching new products and building brand awareness, while Facebook’s tools are better for driving direct sales and retaining customers.
Understanding the targeting options on each platform is key to creating successful campaigns.
Targeting Options: Pinterest vs. Facebook
Pinterest and Facebook offer distinct ways to target audiences, giving CPG brands various tools to fine-tune their advertising strategies. Picking the right approach based on campaign goals can help boost both reach and ROI.
Pinterest Targeting Options
Pinterest focuses on user intent and discovery, giving advertisers the following options:
- Target by demographics like age, gender, location, and language
- Use interest targeting based on topics users engage with
- Keyword targeting to reach people actively searching
- Broader targeting for related topics
Facebook Targeting Options
Facebook’s targeting taps into its rich user data, offering advertisers tools like:
- Targeting customers or website visitors
- Finding similar audiences to existing customers
- Behavioral and interest-based targeting
- Targeting based on life events, job titles, and more
While Facebook often comes with higher CPMs, research from Till Agency shows it frequently delivers better conversions [1].
Comparison Table: Pinterest vs. Facebook Targeting
| Targeting Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Intent-based discovery | Behavioral data |
| Custom Audience Options | Customer lists only | Website visitors, app users, offline data |
| Interest Targeting | From saved pins/searches | From social interactions |
| Keyword Targeting | Available | Not available |
| Lookalike Audiences | Basic targeting | Advanced modeling |
| Geographic Targeting | Country/metro areas | Zip code-level targeting |
"Pinterest’s recent move to open its ad platform to all brands has the potential to significantly disrupt budgets this year, especially among marketers seeking to test direct response advertisements and target forward-looking mobile users." – Marketing Dive [4]
Pinterest’s keyword targeting works well for seasonal campaigns, while Facebook’s advanced lookalike audience tools are perfect for scaling successful strategies. Both platforms provide unique opportunities for CPG brands looking to optimize ad performance.
sbb-itb-6768865
10 Tips for Improving Pinterest and Facebook Ads
These tips are designed to help CPG marketers fine-tune their ad strategies, whether the goal is discovery or driving conversions.
Tip 1: Align Ads with User Intent
Pinterest users often focus on planning and discovering products, while Facebook users are more responsive to time-sensitive offers. Adjust your messaging accordingly: use inspirational, forward-looking content on Pinterest and emphasize urgency or limited-time deals on Facebook. For example, promote seasonal items early on Pinterest and reserve Facebook for flash sales or exclusive offers.
Tip 2: Choose the Right Ad Formats
Each platform has its own visual strengths. On Pinterest, opt for high-quality vertical images with a 2:3 aspect ratio. On Facebook, make use of carousel ads and short videos that grab attention in crowded feeds.
Tip 3: Take Advantage of Pinterest’s Longevity
Pinterest ads have a longer shelf life compared to Facebook. Focus on creating content that taps into ongoing trends or seasonal interests. Evergreen content works particularly well here since it stays relevant and continues to attract engagement over time.
Tip 4: Leverage Keyword Targeting on Pinterest
Pinterest’s keyword targeting is a powerful way to reach active shoppers. Concentrate on specific product-related and seasonal keywords. This is especially effective for CPG brands, as Pinterest users often begin their product research months in advance.
Tip 5: Use Lookalike and Custom Audiences on Facebook
Upload your customer database to create custom audiences, and then use Facebook’s lookalike modeling to scale your campaigns. This lets you target people who share similar behaviors with your best customers, increasing the chances of conversions.
Tip 6: Experiment with Interest Targeting on Both Platforms
Run campaigns on both Pinterest and Facebook to compare performance metrics like cost per click, engagement, and conversions. This data will help you identify which platform delivers the best results for your goals.
Tip 7: Adjust Placements and Budgets
Experiment with different ad placements – such as Pinterest search results or Facebook news feeds – and allocate your budget based on performance metrics like CPMs and conversion rates. This helps ensure you’re investing in the most effective areas.
Tip 8: Use Cross-Platform Analytics
Tap into Google Analytics 4 (GA4) to track conversions across Pinterest and Facebook. This will give you a clearer picture of the customer journey and help you understand how each platform contributes to your goals.
Tip 9: Continuously Refine Campaigns
Ongoing improvement is key to maintaining a strong ROI. Test different creatives, tweak targeting criteria, and adjust bidding strategies based on what the data tells you.
"Pinterest’s recent move to open its ad platform to all brands has the potential to significantly disrupt budgets this year, especially among marketers seeking to test direct response advertisements and target forward-looking mobile users." – Marketing Dive [4]
Choosing the Best Platform for Your CPG Brand
Evaluate Audience and Platform Fit
Selecting the right platform depends on how well it matches your audience’s habits and your campaign goals. Pinterest, for example, excels at planning and discovery, making it a great choice for CPG brands in beauty, home goods, and food. Its core audience – women aged 25-44 – is highly engaged in these areas. On the other hand, Facebook offers a broader reach across various age groups, making it better suited for campaigns focused on quick conversions.
Here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Metric | ||
|---|---|---|
| CPM (Cost per 1,000 impressions) | Lower costs | Higher costs but wider reach |
| User Intent | Planning and discovery | Immediate engagement |
| Campaign Duration | Better for long-term visibility | Better for short-term results |
| Primary Demographics | Women 25-44 | Broad range of age groups |
| Ideal Use | Building awareness, sparking inspiration | Driving direct conversions |
By reviewing these metrics, you can align your campaign with the platform that fits your objectives. Once you’ve narrowed it down, use data-driven testing to fine-tune your approach.
Use A/B Testing
Test your campaigns on both platforms to see which delivers better results for your goals. Focus on these key performance indicators (KPIs):
- Conversion tracking: Compare how each platform handles attributions (Facebook uses a 7-day click/1-day view model, while Pinterest tracks over a longer engagement window).
- Cost efficiency: Look at CPM rates and the overall return on investment (ROI).
- Engagement metrics: Assess click-through rates and how users interact with your content.
Rather than sticking to just one platform, combine their strengths. Use Pinterest to build awareness and inspire your audience early on. Then, retarget those users on Facebook with campaigns designed to drive conversions. This step-by-step approach helps you get the most out of each platform, maximizing your ROI by aligning Pinterest with awareness and Facebook with conversions [1][2].
Conclusion
Key Points Recap
Pinterest and Facebook Ads each bring their own strengths to the table for CPG brands. Pinterest shines when it comes to discovery and building awareness, while Facebook is a go-to for driving conversions with its advanced targeting tools. Pinterest’s focus on discovery-driven shopping and lower costs makes it perfect for awareness campaigns. On the other hand, Facebook’s behavioral targeting and retargeting capabilities make it highly effective for converting leads.
When the goal is awareness, Pinterest offers lower CPMs and long-lasting visibility. For conversions, Facebook’s precise targeting and retargeting tools take the lead. The real key? Using the 10 tips shared earlier to make the most of each platform’s features and align them with your marketing objectives.
Advice for CPG Marketers
To get the best results from both platforms, focus on making decisions based on data and fine-tuning your strategies regularly. Use cross-channel analytics to monitor performance and adjust your approach for long-term success. Instead of seeing Pinterest and Facebook as competitors, think of them as complementary tools that work together.
Here’s how to approach it:
- Start with clear goals: Decide whether your focus is on awareness or conversions before picking your platform mix.
- Test and measure: Use cross-channel analytics to evaluate performance across both platforms [1].
- Adjust campaigns regularly: Make updates based on performance data to keep improving results.
- Distribute your budget wisely: Allocate funds based on what each platform does best and your specific campaign goals.
FAQs
Pinterest vs. Facebook Ads: Which is Best for Your Goals?
Pinterest and Facebook cater to different marketing needs, especially in the CPG space. Pinterest is ideal for raising brand awareness and sparking interest, thanks to its lower CPMs and longer ad visibility. On the other hand, Facebook is better suited for driving conversions with its advanced targeting options and variety of ad formats.
A smart strategy often blends the two. Pinterest’s focus on discovery makes it great for introducing products and building awareness. Facebook, with its precise targeting, is perfect for converting that interest into sales. Many CPG brands start with Pinterest to generate awareness and then use Facebook to retarget those who show interest, focusing on conversions [1].
Here’s a quick side-by-side look:
| Platform Comparison | ||
|---|---|---|
| Primary Metrics | Engagement based on views | Conversions based on clicks |
| Ad Longevity | Longer visibility (weeks/months) | Shorter-term impact (days) |
| User Journey Stage | Discovery and planning | Decision-making and purchasing |
Use cross-channel analytics to track how your campaigns perform and adjust your strategy accordingly [1][2]. By understanding what each platform brings to the table, you can align them to guide customers seamlessly through their journey.
